by Emily Chan
Imagine you’re sitting and making toys in China to help pay for your families’ living needs. You have been working for hours and hours. Then, you realize that the 30 cents an hour wage that you’re receiving isn’t going to take you very far. Your hands and feet are getting tired, but you can’t take a break or you will be punished. Now, imagine that you’re 5 years old.
Unfortunately, this type of lifestyle isn’t that farfetched from the lives of many 5 to 14-year-old children around the world. Except instead of living in China, you could be living in Malaysia, Thailand, or Vietnam; instead of making toys, you could also be making shoes, clothing, rugs, chocolate, bananas, or coffee.
There are nearly one million children who are being exploited into making hand-knotted rugs all around the world. There are 250 MILLION children working in these sweatshops in third world countries. In Pakistan, 75% of their carpet-weavers are girls under age 14. Their needs are even more basic than ours; an education, freedom of speech, and equal pay. These are all things that many people take for granted.
The working conditions, as many know, are less than perfect (to say the least). In carpet factories, children are exposed to carpet dust, malnutrition, and beatings when they try to escape. They receive not only verbal and physical abuse, but also sexual abuse from their bosses. These children are also uneducated, which is something that all children are supposed to be promised. In a certain case, there was a four-year-old, Iqbal Masih, who was sold to a sweatshop by his parents. He was only able to escape at age ten, thanks to the Bonded Labour Liberation Front (BLLF), which is a civil rights group. Iqbal’s life came to a tragic end when he was murdered, at age 12, when he was returning home. It was the same carpet industry that he used to work for that ended his life and stopped him from spreading his story.
So why would anyone willingly enforce these working conditions onto young children? The answer is money. It’s simple, easy, and cheap for manufacturers to have children work for wages that may as well not even exist. They are able to reap mass profits, and they are very rarely caught. When the inspectors come to make sure the workshop is running smoothly, the managers get a phone call first, to let them know of their arrival. Unfortunately, this warning is set so far ahead that the managers have enough time to get rid of all the child workers and replace them with adults who quickly rehearse what to say.
This is NOT ethical, and this is not right. There have been debates as to whether child labour is okay; if the children are out of jobs, then there will not be ANY income for the family. When you get down to it, it doesn’t matter! No matter what the cost, we must stop this. If we allow ourselves to take the easy road and agree that there’s nothing we can do, child labour will never end.
Here’s a better example for you. The 2003 National Labour Committee report stated that an average Honduran worker sews clothing for 43 cents an hour. After meals and transportation, this worker is left with 80 cents per DAY. This money must go towards rent, bills, childcare, school, medicine, emergencies, and whatever else. Not mentioning that these workers have probably taken out loans along the way that they need to pay off. So, they are already stuck in the whirlpool of exploitation, and the only way to get them out is to stop it all together.
Here’s another person taking the stand. Do you remember he young boy who was murdered because be escaped for the cotton sweatshop? Well, this death inspired 12-year-old Craig Kielburger (at the time) to start an organization to convince consumers to learn about the horrors of child labour and buy sweatshop-free products. This organization is known as Free the Children.
Usually, articles tend to end with the speech that we must get involved and end the horrors. In this article, you can sit back and relax, because some companies have beaten you to it. Some companies that have devoted their time into buying sweatshop free products are: Co-op America, No Sweat, and the popular American Apparel. The only thing that we need to do is support these anti-child labour businesses and organisations. If we are like the average citizen, we will spend that extra 28% to buy products that are sweatshop free.
I have a question…
What is Free the Children actually doing about child labour today??? it says in your article that they are obviously telling others about it and all… but what are they actually doing about it?
Hey Karl!
Good question… I’ll try my best to answer it. Mainly, Free the Children is youth-led. It says on their website that 65% of all of the donations that they receive were raised by the youth, so that’s pretty cool. They go around to high schools (They came to Windermere!!), explaining the true horrors of Child Labour. Then, they try to inspire those youth to join in and help. It says that “Free The Children has built more than 500 schools around the world and has reached more than one million young people through outreach in North America.” on their website. Basically, they raise money and then put the money towards trying to build a school in a country less fortunate than us.
Yeah, so this was a looong explanation, and I hope I answered your questions… if you have any more, ask away! Or, go to http://www.freethechildren.com for other info and how to get involved.
THANNKKK YOUUU for your awesome question!
-Emily
cool, so you know what i noticed?
your name is bigger than mitchell’s on the web cloud. HAHA and apparently he was jealous.
“my name was the biggest for like 2 months, then all of the sudden emily’s and jessica’s got HUGE” or something along the lines of that. ahhahah
XD
whoops, i meant “tag cloud” not web cloud.
actually, sadly, I did notice that… : ) My name is humongous! (don’t worry, I won’t let my head explode with the self-confidence)
oh my gosh! i didn’t know that so many people were being exploited! why are people letting this happen! and why are the people runnign these factories so mean and coldhearted!! children, especially the young ones, should not be allowed to work in such horrible conditions! they have no say about their future and they won’t have one if they try to run away! but even IF they got away, they wouldn’t have a good future because they we not educated!
thank you for informing me!!
it’s great that you were able to get something out of my article : ) Thanks for the feedback– and keep it up; making your own philosophies and looking into things that are new to you…that’s how you’ll get even MORE informed (although it seems that you’re on the right track)! : )
let me just say that if you want to learn more about sweatshops and the world of retail/branding/consumerism, then you need to read “no logo” by naomi klein.
your article does a good job of looking at the ethical side of sweatshops, but you don’t explain a lot about the logistics and how/where these sweatshops actually exist. it would make your argument a lot stronger if you commented on some of the things she wrote in her book… but the main thing is that you should definitely google “export processing zones”, or EPZs for short.
it also begins with the consumer’s education. we’re all so brainwashed from the beginning to buy these things that we don’t need, so that we can look good and pretend we feel good. but in the end, what is it really all worth?
woah, everything thats going on with child labour is sooooooooooooo sad
thx for letting me know all this
/
(happy because of infromation sad because child labor is sooooo wrong)
i cant believe that people would actually do that to innocent children who are poor and need money to support their family. i mean are they short of brain cells or something?
Yeah, it is pretty atrocious! and hard to comprehend because it’s so different from our norm but unfortunately that’s the world we live in and hopefully with time, education and action we can change it
nhaa their not short of brain cells, there pretty smart actually. Less regulations over there, cheap labor= more profit.
btw you shouldn’t say that something is NOT ethical.. that’s not up for you to decide, whats ethical or not is subjective.
profit is not always everything especially because these corporations make billions as it is! giving their workers decent wages so they can actually feed their families and make ends meet would not hurt them, they would still make profit! and really how much money do you really need?
definition of ethics: that branch of philosophy dealing with values relating to human conduct, with respect to the rightness and wrongness of certain actions and to the goodness and badness of the motives and ends of such actions.
i think it’s fair for her to say that child labour is unethical because clearly the kids are not treated fairly and dont recieve a lot for their hard work and then theres the companies who make billions and we all know that they definently could spare some money and make the working conditions better and increase wages
they are definently treating these kids wrong and its not fair!
All I said was they aren’t dumb or missing braincells.. I mean they don’t earn their billions of dollars by being retarded. I agree with you guys, their actions and the way they abuse and exploit children is wrong, but honestly.. it’s pretty smart business move and a good way to reap profit. How much money do you really need? I don’t know, but when you become corrupt even billions of dollars isn’t enough.
Also I don’t think its fair at all for her to say so bluntly that its unethical. Might be better if she said “in my opinion” but to so say that its unethical just because she thinks so is wrong.
btw your definition doesn’t help your point at all especially this part “with respect to the rightness and wrongness of certain actions and to the goodness and badness of the motives and ends of such actions.”
Good and bad, right and wrong.. also very subjective. If someone was to disagree and say that child labor was good, who are we to say there wrong, its their view on the topic. Even in this article it says that there have been debates over child labor being right. I’m sure those people have some good arguments to.
But yes, I agree with you overall, its not fair. That isn’t something new to you though is it? I’m sure you know already that life is arbitrary and unfair.